Where are Manchester’s neighborhoods?

The darker blue areas represent the core parts of neighborhoods as defined by average people; the lighter areas are less defined. Image from the Boston Globe.

Recently, the Boston Globe ran a piece about the perception of city neighborhoods by average people. Using an online mapping software, they asked people to draw the boundaries of the city’s famous (and not-so-famous) neighborhoods. What they found was that popular perception of what made up, say, the South End differed somewhat from what the City officially defined the neighborhood boundaries as, not to mention how real estate agents stretched the boundaries into lesser-known nearby areas.

That last bit is something that Fortress Manchester looked at with the desirable North End in Manchester. According to the planning department’s map of city neighborhoods, the North End starts at Salmon Street, but depending on whom you ask, the North End can extend as far south as Bridge Street or be cut off at Webster Street. Unlike the set lines of cities or even the river between the West Side and Downtown, most neighborhood boundaries are fuzzy. Some areas seem like they’re not even part of a neighborhood at all.

So we were wondering how people perceived of neighborhoods in Manchester. The neighborhoods in the Queen City aren’t as well-known–outside the city, for sure, but even locally–as those in Boston, but there are some that have strong identities: Downtown, the North End, the Hollow, the West Side (which is really too big and diverse to be just one neighborhood), and increasingly Rimmon Heights. There are other historic neighborhoods that exist mostly only on city maps and a few businesses: Janesville, Hallsville, Youngsville, Bakersville, Piscataquog, Notre Dame and Amoskeag. Then, there are other areas that are more defined by a major street or intersection than the neighborhood around them: the Hollow (again), Granite Square, Second Street, Webster Street, Kelley Street, and sometimes even Elm Street. The city planning department is trying to revive some of these neighborhood identities, albeit with new names in some cases. And then there are neighborhoods that the planning department seemed to create (not that that’s necessarily a bad thing): Straw/Smyth, Wolfe Park, Northwest and Wellington, among others.

In a city of Manchester’s size, having a series of neighborhoods with strong identities is crucial to the vibrancy of the city as a whole, and to the individual neighborhoods throughout it. Otherwise, what makes a particular area special or different? Right now, though, there aren’t many neighborhoods that are easy to identify. Fewer still have their own neighborhood center, a place with locally geared shops, restaurants, cafes and other places to naturally congregate and run errands without going downtown or to the strip malls on the edge of town.

manchester_neighborhoods
This map from the City’s master plan shows neighborhoods and neighborhood centers, as identified by the City. Like the map of Boston from the Globe, it blurs the boundaries between most neighborhoods.

The City’s master plan does identify at least eleven neighborhood business centers (also called neighborhood village centers), areas that “provide services, jobs and a sense of community for the neighborhood,” and suggests that they “should be strengthened through redevelopment, development of more mixed uses and a design framework that encourages a walkable area,” but the zoning and promotion of most of those centers is lagging far behind. We’ve put together a map of the neighborhood centers identified by the City, along with those areas zoned to be walkable, mixed-use districts (and other areas that we think should be rezoned as such). The master plan rightfully emphasizes the importance of strong neighborhood centers to serve as the core of the city’s neighborhoods, but the zoning, planning and promotion of those areas really needs to be stepped up.

Future Rimmon Heights & Notre Dame
Places like Lafayette Park in Rimmon Heights/Notre Dame can be focal points of a neighborhood, but it takes the people there to give it a unique identity.

Downtown Manchester is continuing to thrive and grow, and it’s the natural focal point for the city and the region, but Manchester is much more than its downtown–after all, the vast majority of people in Manchester live in the neighborhoods outside of downtown. Just as Manchester needs to implement and follow its master plan as a whole, comprehensive plans need to be developed for individual neighborhoods. One such plan was developed for Rimmon Heights several years ago, and it has been partially implemented, but there’s much work left to be done. Just across the city line, a similar plan is being developed for Pinardville in Goffstown. Of course, it’s not enough for there to be a plan or even to expect the City to implement it. There need to be strong grassroots groups, like the one in Rimmon Heights, to promote individual neighborhoods and give them a unique identity.

So what do you think of the neighborhoods as defined by the city? Do they follow the rough boundaries that you’d expect? How about the names? Some of them are easy to rally around (Rimmon Heights and the North End, for example), but others, like Straw/Smyth, are pretty clumsy. What would you suggest as a different name for any of the neighborhoods? And how about the neighborhood centers–do they make sense? Is anything missing? Most important, though, what can be done to strengthen the neighborhood centers? To make them more walkable focal points within the city? And what can be done to give various neighborhoods a greater sense of identity and uniqueness?

About these ads

6 thoughts on “Where are Manchester’s neighborhoods?

  1. As a resident of the so-called “Smyth/Straw” neighborhood, I agree that it is rather clumsily named. Several years ago my Neighborhood Watch group had a tough time coming up with a place-based name for our group. We ended up selecting Oak Park as our focal point as the vast majority of us live with four or five blocks of the park.Thus we refer to ourselves as the Oak Park Neighborhood Watch and to our neighborhood as the Oak Park neighborhood. It’s certainly smaller that the City-designated “Smyth-Straw” neighborhood, but it works for us.

    1. That’s a good point–even within the larger official neighborhoods, there are smaller distinctive areas: Oak Park (which is a much nicer name) in Straw/Smyth, Granite Square in Piscataquog, the area around Stark Park and River Road in the North End, the Hollow in Hallsville, and of course the Millyard in Downtown. But whether it’s the official neighborhood or a smaller informal neighborhood, a good name is essential if people are going to identify with it. Oak Park works well for the immediate area, but there’s got to be better name for the whole area. I wonder if you or any other residents have any ideas?

  2. I would like to see something happen with the Somerville neighborhood. That is where I grew up and I can still see a lot of potential. With a little investment and community outreach, Wilson St. from Valley to Somerville (and really, parts of Somerville from Wilson to Taylor) could really be a nice little neighborhood center.

    1. That area has a lot of potential. It’s an area I know well from growing up myself (though I never lived there), and a neighborhood I visited frequently when Jewell & the Beanstalk was open. It’s an unusual area since it’s not on any major thoroughfares, but along what was once a streetcar line that went down Wilson Street and turned onto Somerville Street. Still, there are a decent number and a good mix of locally geared businesses there.

      It’s too bad that the Beanstalk isn’t around anymore, because a cafe like that can serve as a strong heart for a neighborhood, and it’s something that Manchester has far too few of. Neighborhood cafes and bars, perhaps even more than traditional restaurants, are excellent gathering spots because of the interaction between people, as long as they are welcoming places for all members of the community.

      Even without the Beanstalk or another similar place, though, there’s a lot of potential there. Somerville could use a neighborhood association or group along the lines of what exists in Rimmon Heights to organize events and promote the neighborhood and its businesses, both to residents of Somerville and city-wide.

  3. I highly recommend everyone sign up for Nextdoor, which is online site that focuses on creating private communities for neighborhoods within towns and cities. The team there reached out to me about breaking up one gigantic Manchester neighborhood into neighborhoods. With LivableMHT’s post here about Manchester’s neighborhoods as guidance, we were able to break up Manchester into similar neighborhoods on Nextdoor.

    https://nextdoor.com/invite/nwvyyugezeuefhdykyvn

    Join and make sure you put your own stamp on your neighborhood.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s